FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Health Workforce Canada (HWC) has developed a series of data and information dashboards to visually pull together existing health workforce data to help health care leaders, decision makers and planners and more in their work.

We see this as just the beginning of a data visualization journey. This page can help users find answers to some of the common questions related to HWC dashboards.

The questions below were received from early users that attended our June 20th, 2024, pop-up session.

We will continue to refresh this page quarterly with the most up-to-date information as the dashboards expand and new data becomes available.

We invite you to connect with us through the feedback form to share your own questions or suggestions and help shape the future of the dashboards and other supporting tools.  

Data Sources

How current is the data?

The recency of the data varies by source and will be updated regularly as the more recent data becomes available. For example, as of September 2024, the dashboards currently contain data for these time periods:

  • CIHI Health Workforce Database (HWDB) – Record-level: 2013 – 2023 (Provider Profiles, Employment, Recruitment & Retention modules) 
  • CIHI Health Workforce Database (HWDB) – Aggregate: 2017 – 2021 (Provider Profiles module) 
  • CIHI Scott’s Medical Database (SMDB): 2013 – 2022 (Provider Profiles and Recruitment & Retention modules) 
  • CIHI Canadian MIS Database (CMDB): fiscal years 2017–2018 – 2021–2023 (Employment module) 
  • Statistics Canada Job Vacancy and Wage Survey (JVWS): fiscal years 2015–2016 – 2022–2023 (Employment module) 
  • Statistics Canada Census of Population: 2013 – 2022 (Recruitment & Retention module)

Users are encouraged to refer to the related methodology notes for more details around data availability and collection periods. There may be instances of data variances or gaps; for example, the COVID-19 pandemic affected the timeliness of reporting in some jurisdictions, impacting data comparability. Collecting, processing, validating, and publishing accurate data is a complex and labour-intensive task. We are committed to supporting our data partners in streamlining and improving this process and aim to bring updated data into these dashboards as soon as it is available.  

If I want more detailed data, how do I get it?    

Data visualizations offered within the dashboards are aggregated at the pan-Canadian and provincial/territorial levels to give a high-level summary of key health workforce trends. Those looking for more detailed data are encouraged to check out our downloadable Data Catalogue and navigate to the How to Access tabs to learn more about the data request process. We have developed an accompanying occupation mapping guide to help you in selecting data holding and occupation name in your request to ensure efficiency in processing your data request.  

Is information on oral health providers included?   

Data on the supply of dentists, dental hygienists and dental assistants is available in the Provider Profiles dashboard, including the total number and the number per 10,000 population. 

 We continue to work with data partners to support collection and availability of more detailed and timely data on oral health and other health care providers. 

Is there any data captured around specialty practice for nursing?    

Most of the data on Canada’s nurses presented within the dashboards is self-reported through the annual license registration/renewal process, which not only supports regulation of the nursing professions but also provides valuable information on head counts, geospatial distribution, employment characteristics, and practice trends.   

Some regulatory colleges collect information on the specialized areas in which health care providers work (e.g., critical care, geriatrics, oncology, pediatrics). These specializations may require formal certifications for clinical practice. Additionally, nurses may also receive on-the-job training to work in specialty areas of practice that would not be captured by a formal certification.  

While aggregated data on nurses’ areas of practice is currently reported in the dashboards (i.e., data is summarized into the areas of direct care, research, administration, and other), CIHI’s Nursing in Canada methodology notes and data standards documentation provide more details on the types of specialties or areas of practice that are collected for nurses. This more granular data may be available through data requests. The process for this is outlined in the How to Access tab in our downloadable Data Catalogue. 

Does migration data show what country IEHPs migrated from? Is there data on volumes of practitioners moving into Canada and where they are going?   

The Provider Profiles dashboard currently provides information on the proportion of licensed health care providers who graduated outside of Canada but does not display detailed information on the countries that IEHPs (internationally educated health professionals) migrated from, nor the volumes of IEHPs moving into Canada and their destinations. Future iterations will look to advance information about IEHPs as more data becomes available, as well as other priority areas. 

For more detailed migration data, including country-specific information, please refer to the CIHI profession-specific data tables. 

Is there any plan to include data on the broader public health workforce? 

HWC recognizes the gap in coverage for several key health professions, including public health professionals. We are committed to working with our data partners and other stakeholders to improve data coverage on more health care providers as the information becomes available and is determined to be fit for use. 

Development

How was this built?

The dashboards developed by HWC are the result of over 20 years of data standardization and collection work by the people of CIHI, Statistics Canada, regulatory colleges, health care workers, employers, governments, advocates and data enthusiasts alike. The initial release was scoped around the data available and fit-for-use at the time. The functionality, usability, and cost of various business intelligence (BI) platforms were assessed, leading to the selection of AWS QuickSight. 

Were subject matter experts in each province consulted when building this? Data from stewards such as CIHI and provincial counts are sometimes different for various reasons.

Yes, subject matter experts from across the country were consulted during the development of the dashboards and continue to provide advice on future directions. HWC has formed a pan-Canadian advisory group consisting of multi-disciplinary experts from professional organizations, employers, CIHI, Statistics Canada, Health Canada, the research community, various levels of government, and more. Additional consultation with provincial and territorial ministries of health as well as regions will help further guide improvements, including on how to provide additional insights and context to the data presented in the dashboards. 

 

We recognize that data from stewards such as CIHI and provincial data counts have historically differed for various reasons, which can complicate comparisons of pan-Canadian data. These differences often arise from varying time periods or methods for data collection across professions and jurisdictions (e.g., calendar years vs. fiscal years, different inclusion/exclusion criteria, etc.). For more detailed information on data collection specific to each data set currently included in the dashboard, please refer to CIHI’s methodology notes 

Functionality

How will access to the tool be managed? Is it subscription based? 

To support the goal of ensuring a sustainable and satisfied health workforce in Canada, the tool will remain fully transparent, open to the public and free to use.  

When exporting a table from the dashboard, does it reflect the filters you have selected? Is there a way to download all the raw data? 

Data tables downloaded from the Workforce in View or Policy Tracker modules will reflect the filters you have selected. To see all raw data in a table format for deeper analysis, you can consult CIHI or Statistics Canada source data tables. Information on and links to source data are always included in the notes section at the bottom of each dashboard. 

Is there an ability to drill down by geography to the community or site level? 

Data are currently available by profession and province and territory. Upcoming updates to the dashboards planned for early 2025 will include breakdowns to the health region level where data is available. We recognize visibility at every level is important and will have a place on our larger dashboard roadmap where possible.  

Do the dashboards offer future projections (e.g., projected shortages of family physicians)? 

HWC dashboards do not currently include health workforce supply and demand projections; however, HWC is committed to catalyzing Canada-wide capacity for health workforce modeling and forecasting.  We are exploring opportunities in the future ways that health workforce forecasting models may be made available.  

Policy Tracker

What is the methodology for collecting the policies in the Policy Tracker?  

The Policy Tracker is developed and maintained by CIHI and is updated quarterly. Relevant policies and interventions relating to defined priority areas are extracted from public announcements on federal, provincial, and territorial governments and professional association’s official websites through manual web scraping. 

The entries are collected using a set of pre-determined scanning criteria and are verified to ensure correctness and consistency across the meta-data entered. Visualizations for total counts across categories are refreshed each quarter and a comparison to the original data source is conducted to validate. 

Where do we go from here?  

Where do we go from here?  

The latter portion of the June 20th, 2024, pop-up discussion included an opportunity for participants to share with us where they’d like to see our dashboards go next. HWC has been actively engaging partners and stakeholders since our formation in November 2023 and it remains an important part of our strategic planning into the future.  

Our team will continue to work with our advisory group, partners and dashboard users to develop a blueprint that will guide future development. The blueprint will connect information needs with available data sources, as well as identify gaps and opportunities to improve data capture and timeliness. These learnings will be a key part of the work HWC is leading to advance a pan-Canadian health workforce data strategy.  

HWC thanks all those who have contributed to the development and publication of these dashboards. Ongoing feedback is welcomed to continue further enhancements and ensure development of a value-add product!